Five Pages Gone, More Email: What Happened When I Cut My Portfolio Down
Photo: Breather breather, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons
My portfolio had eleven pages. I could not have told you what four of them were for.
That bothered me enough to do something I had been avoiding: an audit with actual numbers, where each page had to justify its existence with evidence instead of vibes. Five pages failed. I deleted them in one evening, backed up the content first, and braced for the traffic to fall off a cliff.
It went the other way. Here is what happened, page by page.
The baseline
I measured ninety days before the cuts and sixty days after. Same analytics tool, same host, no redesign in between — just pages removed and the contact link made more prominent.
- Before: 742 sessions, 3 inquiries. Contact rate of 0.4%.
- After: 611 sessions, 9 inquiries. Contact rate of 1.5%.
Traffic went down 18%, mostly because the resources page and archive were pulling search traffic that had never converted anyway. Contact rate nearly quadrupled. Nine inquiries is not a mountain of data and I am not going to pretend otherwise, but the direction was consistent month over month, and every one of those nine was a real conversation.
One more number that surprised me: average time on site dropped from 2:14 to 1:38. People were spending less time and doing more. I had been optimizing for the wrong thing for years.
Page 1: the services page
What it was supposed to do: explain what I offer so people could decide to hire me.
What it actually did: listed six things, three of which I had not done since 2023. It read like a menu from a restaurant that changed chefs.
Six hundred words of I do design systems, front-end architecture, technical writing, workshops, audits, and occasional consulting. Six offers is not a decision. It is a shrug. And it sat one click away from my actual work, competing with it for attention.
Verdict: deleted. The work pages say what I do better than a list ever could. If someone wants to know whether I do workshops, they can ask — and asking is exactly what I want them to do.
Page 2: the testimonials
What it was supposed to do: provide social proof.
What it actually did: provide three quotes from people whose names I had spelled in four different formats across the page. Two had job titles that were out of date. Nobody had ever refreshed them because nobody had ever asked.
Here is the thing I genuinely believe after this exercise: a testimonial page is a place where social proof goes to be ignored. The proof that works is embedded — a sentence in a project write-up about what the client said when it shipped, sitting right next to the work. When it is on its own page, it is a claim without context.
Verdict: deleted. The two quotes I actually liked now live inside the project pages they belong to, with full names and links.
Page 3: the 2,400-word about page
What it was supposed to do: tell my story, build trust, be memorable.
What it actually did: start with a childhood memory, run through a career timeline, and bury the useful part — what I am doing now and what I want to be doing next — around paragraph nineteen.
I looked at the scroll depth. Sixty-two percent of visitors left before the halfway mark. Of the ones who reached paragraph nineteen, most had already bounced.
So I cut it to 480 words. First paragraph: what I do. Second: what I am looking for. Third: three projects with links. Then a short, deliberately human section at the bottom for anyone who wants the long version, because I still like those people.
Verdict: rewritten, not deleted. But it counts, because the page I had was doing negative work. It was making people do homework to find out whether I was worth emailing.
Page 4: the resources page
What it was supposed to do: be generous, share the tools I use, attract links.
What it actually did: list forty-one links in alphabetical order. Half of them were dead. It got decent search traffic — about 190 sessions in the ninety days — and produced exactly zero inquiries and two newsletter signups.
This was the hardest cut because it was the page I was proudest of. Generosity feels good. But a link dump is not generosity, it is a filing cabinet, and the internet has plenty of those with better maintenance.
Verdict: deleted. The tools I actually use now get a sentence in the posts where they matter, in context, with a reason.
Page 5: the archive
What it was supposed to do: show the depth of my writing.
What it actually did: paginate ninety-plus posts by date with no filtering, no topics, and no reason for anyone to scroll past the first screen. Twenty-two sessions in ninety days visited page two of the archive. Twenty-two.
Verdict: deleted. The notes index now groups posts by theme, which is how people actually look for things, and search covers the rest.
What the cuts actually changed
Two things, and neither was the thing I expected.
The first was navigational. My header went from six links to three. The contact page went from 88 views in ninety days to 41 views in sixty days — fewer total views, but a much higher share of total sessions, and it is now one tap from every single page.
The second was psychological, and it took me a while to admit it. I had been using those pages as a way to avoid the uncomfortable question of whether my work was good enough to speak for itself. A services page is easier to write than a case study. A resources page is easier than an opinion. Every one of those five pages was somewhere to hide.
The part where I stay honest
Nine inquiries in sixty days, from a starting point of three in ninety, is a small sample. It is possible some of this is seasonality, or that the shortened about page happened to land in front of the right two people in the same week. I am not going to build a course on this.
But the mechanism is not mysterious. Fewer pages meant fewer choices at the moment someone decided whether to email me. Every page I removed was a page that could absorb a click without ever answering the one question a visitor has: should I talk to this person?
My test now is simple. Before I add a page to this site, I have to finish one sentence about what it does that leads to a project link or a draft email. If I cannot finish the sentence, the page does not go up.
Eleven pages became six. The site got smaller and the inbox got busier. That trade is the whole point.